With "In-house experts" such as these who needs a Homeland Security plan? Following is an example of "expertness" in Islam, when asked for Ayas and Surrahs to back this "experts expertise", someone who makes sure to add (sws) after Mohammed's name, as only a Muslim would do, we are told the expert is actually a Christian (taqqiya) and does not want to banter with us "armchair quarterbacks". What a shame!

Tell us what you think. After receiving a copy of our analysis of the "false Ossama tape ", this is what we received. We have also added  feedback about our analysis from those who have been there, such as a former CIA operative, a security professional, and a former Secret Service professional, which are attached at the bottom of this piece. Everything in black font is from the "in-house expert" and those who think he is really one!

 

Our in-house expert's, not-to-kind evaluation follows:

 "I don't really like this persons analysis at all. He or she is very rhetoric about how they put their own analysis into words and they apparently don't know as much about Islam and the sunnah and haddith as they claim.

 Avoiding the topic with personal attack.

 Analysis is not done to match someone’s likes or dislikes, but to get to the bottom of the topic being analyzed.

 Changing tense from “he or she” to “they”.

 Of course this is my “own analysis”

 Yes, it is written about trim the moustache and let the beard flow, but also it is written that the beard shall be kept neat and clean and it should not be any longer than the length of placing your fist under your chin. 

 Points to contradiction in Koran (of which there are numerous) mentioning “let the beard flow”, then “length of placing your fist under your chin.”

 However, some muslims follow that and some don't follow it.  Alot of the Wahabbi and Sulefy people let their beards grow much longer than the length of the fist and they rarely, if at all, trim it, but it is not cause for killing for doing it or not.

 The word is “Salafi” not “Sulefy”, misses the irony of reasons Muslims use to kill and destroy – a simple cartoon caused the deaths of numerous people around the world, hair salons and music shops have been blown up in Pakistan because barbers trimmed beards

 He is correct in the words that they struck us and will continue to strike us because of our occupation of the arab land.  

 He is incorrect in attributing the above to me. Please read my analysis again

 The Christians in Iraq are being run out and killed by shiite militia's, not sunni terrorist linked to al-Queda.

 Facts are wrong and protective of the Sunni

 The Jews being killed in Israel are linked to both Fatah (who the US and Israel currently support and fund) and Hamas (who is supported and funded by Hezbollah, the shiite and Iran).

 Not sure what his point is here – are they, the Fatah, Hamas, Hizbullah et al, not Muslim? 

 He speaks of the possibility of Adam Pearlman being a CIA agent on the inside and possibly how the tape got out unexpectedly.  Why does the CIA need Pearlman when Bin Laden himself was an operative for the CIA for many years (all the way up until their falling out in July of 2001) and led much of the resistance that the CIA trained in Afghanistan to fight the Russians in the first gulf war.

 Misses irony of Gadhan being either Mossad or CIA.

Totally fabricates bin Laden being a CIA operative. Truly does not understand the jihad against the Ruskies – I happened to be there and “discuss” with Mujahaideen

 As far as his mention of Tom Tancredo... he is crazy to mention the thought of bombing the mulsim holy sites at Mecca and Medinah.  I don't think he's considered how that would completely shut down the Middle East meaning NO oil and how many Americans would innocently be captured, kidnapped and killed over such an act by the poor, under-educated, radicals in the Islamic society of all Middle Eastern countries. 

 Attacks Tancredo. Scare mongering about “NO oil”.

Would the American’s be innocent, or would the Islamic kidnappers “innocently” kidnap the Americans?

 Not to forget, we have 170,000 soldiers that would face hell or a massive hostage situation in Iraq if he were to do that. 

 More scare mongering and ingratiation with the “we have 170,000….”

 Does Tancredo also forget that we have about 6 to 8 million muslims inside the US already (depending on which poll you rely on) that can cause a significant amount of destruction, insecurity and hell inside America for the bombing of the muslim holy sites?

Tancredo is just plain "stupidity" talking! 

 More scare mongering and threats of the destructive evil of Islamic terrorists.

Really needs to learn to write English – “stupidity talking”????

 As far as John Edwards talk of invading Pakistan, thats all America needs to deal with in our already fragile record of foreign policy right now.

 Does Edwards remember Pakistan has a nuclear weapon?  Why they may not reach America with it, they can certainly reach Saudi Arabia (where our oil is), Qatar (where Middle East CENTCOM is), the UK (our closest Allie) and Israel (who we always defend) and even Iraq (where we have 170,000 troops) if they want! Edwards is "stupidity" talking as well.

 Attacks Edwards. Belongs to the “Islamic Bomb” club, where does he get the notion that Islamic Pakistan would bomb Saudi, the “land of the two holy placeas”?

There he goes again with the “stupidity talking” nonsense. UK is an ally not “allie”

 I feel suprised that this person is a LEGITIMATE writer and making analysis on such issues in this way.

 He should be “surprised” not “suprised” as they are a few of us who lived among the Muslims and understand them well and the teachings of the Koran 

 It doesn't matter how many TIMES you read the Quran, if you don't understand the MEANING of the Iyah (verses) of the Quran, then the words mean NOTHING to you. 

 Uses boldface to get message across. How does one “understand the MEANING”? Wait for Gabriel to explain?

 Most Muslims in the world do not speak or understand Arabic, maybe the words mean “NOTHING” to them too?

 The Quran is attached like a chain from the first word of al-Fatiyah (The Opening) all the way to the last word of An-Nas (The People) which is 114 surah's (chapters) of the Quran. 

 So?

 If you have never studied how to understand the Quran and the code of the Quran from the arabic language (NOT the english translation of the arabic Quran) then you know absolutely nothing about what it really means or represents in these surah's and Iyah's. 

 Ah, now we get to codes, and the old Muslim argument of “NOT the English transalation…” apologist line

 This is VERY clear in writings by Robert Spencer and David Horowitz who always take one Iyah of the Quran and they tell a PART of the truth, which in NO way represents the true code of the Quran and the meaning of the Iyah.

 There we go again, attack my friend Robert Spencer and others and avoid the topic

 FOR EXAMPLE:  In Robert Spencers book he claims the Prophet Mohammed (sws) married his wife Aysha at the age of 8 years old.

 TRUE... in words but not in meaning from the Quran code.

 Wow, this is some analysis by some “expert”, it is “TRUE” but not true.

Aisha  was six when she was betrothed to Muhammed, and nine when the marriage was consummated.

 The truth is, during the culture of that time, if two people who close to each other, like in this case, Prophet Mohammed and his best friend Abu Bakr Saddiq, then it was common to "engage" (the english word) your daughter to your best friend, or your friends son, etc. 

 Abu Bakr Saddiq ENGAGED his daughter Aysha to Mohammed (sws) when she was 9 years old, however, they were not married until she was at least 13 because Islam forbids any girl to marriage before she reaches puberty and the physical changes of a woman.

 Please produce the Surrah and Ayat from the Koran that forbids any girl to marriage before she reaches puberty – thank you!

 These "experts" and "scholars" of Islam really tickle me at how LITTLE they know about Islam.  They think just because they read the ENGLISH translation of the ARABIC Quran that they get the meaning of it, but they know NOTHING about the Code of the Quran and how it attaches to everything in it and how to break the code to understand the TRUE meaning and explanation behind each Iyah. 

 I hate being tickled and hate tickling people sir, that is one thing I will never be accused of in a court of law!

 So you are now a code breaker eh? Is that the "Da Vinci" code, or the "Da Mohammed" code?

 You should be working for the NSA, they are PC too.

 To make the answer short... this person does not interest me or impress me at all with their analysis

 My analysis is not to interest you or impress you, I couldn’t care less.

 My duty is to tell the truth and not be a willing accomplice to Islamic terror and “political misspeak” at which you seem to be an EXPERT

 

Paddy,

 

You had actually said: Your "in-house expert" is a Muslim, yes?" As I said, he is a US Citizen and not of Mid-eastern decent. He is a Christian, which has nothing to do with his response to your analysis. You see there are the "armchair quarterbacks" and then there are those who are actually "players in the game."

 

I guess I'm a bit confused why you are personalizing this? You asked what I thought and I passed your request on to our extremely qualified person to answer. Now you are not happy with his response and revert to calling him names and refer to him as incompetent when I tell you he has been in Iraq training their police. I, nor the person who reviewed your material are interesting in bantering with you.

 

Every time you send me an email, it is answered with an auto-responder because of the 60 job applicants we receive daily. 

 

 

Roger Phillips
Homeland Security Defense Coalition
Homeland Security University project
A non-profit National Security Organization

 

Following is the feed back from:

(CIA Operative who has been down-range all his life)

Hey, Paddy -

I liked your article -  very colorful, descriptive and, of course, right on target.

 

Maybe you should be a writer in your spare time...! 

 

B-Safe

 

(Former Secret Service)

Very well written, Uncle.  I am at flight school studying and doing
well.  I am keeping a very low profile.  Back to PhD in the Spring.  I
am still mulling the idea we talked about on the phone.  I will not
forget.  I hope to see you and the gang soon.

 

(Security Specialist)

You weren't totally clear on your position I think people are confused! LOL!

You be safe! Hey you may need to make a few calls.

I am going to learn as much as possible and be a faithful helper but I am not willing to subject myself to the confusion for too long....

Alas, we are just "armchair quarterbacks" and not "players in the game".